In 1970, James Mooney (Josh O’Connor) walks into a gallery with two accomplices, and steals four paintings in broad daylight. But while they pull off the initial heist, holding onto their plunder proves a greater challenge.

Acclaimed Kelly Reichardt (Certain Women, First Cow) wrote and directed this atmospheric art heist film. It’s a notable departure from her previous works, known for their minimalist style and understated narratives. The film also marks a significant career milestone for O’Connor, whose performance has stirred awards season buzz alongside his performances in highly anticipated 2025 releases The History of Sound and Wake Up Dead Man.

The film poignantly evokes 1970s suburban Massachusetts, as O’Connor’s down-on-his-luck father of two seeks to fashion himself into a criminal genius, whilst keeping his domestic life from falling apart at the seams. Whilst a period piece, The Mastermind “connects to something larger about an America losing its way” (ScreenDaily).